Artwork Collection and Review
You may collect physical or digital Reflections entries, based on state requirements and what is easiest for participants, families, PTA volunteers and volunteer reviewers. However, how you collect entries will affect how you review entries.
Consider the following to choose how you will collect and review entries:
- Physical Collection and Review: Collect physical entries, including media entries on USBs, CDs, etc. Display works with titles and artist statements. Show media entries using a tablet or computer. Reviewers rotate and score each entry on a scoring sheet.
- Digital Collection and Review: Collect entries virtually (form, email, digital storage platform). Organize entries in virtual folders, assign numbers to each to keep anonymous. Share digital copies and scorecards. Score each entry and submit via email or form.
Upon request, National PTA may be able to provide a template Google Entry Form to support digital entry collection. Email
Reflections@PTA.org to learn more.
Planning Tip
National PTA recommends a digital collection and review process for easier management and preventing loss or damage.
Reflections Scoring Criteria
All levels of Reflections, including National PTA, use the same standard, consistent scoring system. This consistency is necessary to conduct a fair and organized review across the program levels.
To conduct your review, provide judges the official Reflections scoring criteria, as outlined in the Reflections Review Packet:
- Interpretation of Theme (40 pts.): How closely the piece relates to the theme, based on the artwork itself and the artist statement.
- Creativity (30 pts.): How creative and original the piece is in its conception of the theme and its presentation.
- Technical Skill (30 pts.): The level of skill demonstrated in the basic principles/techniques of the arts area.
Learn More
The Craft an Entry page provides tips and ideas to help students better incorporate the theme into their artwork.
How to Host a Reflections Review
Understanding the steps involved in your review will make planning and hosting your review easier and more efficient.
After collecting your entries, follow these steps for how to host a Reflections review:
- Prepare Artwork for Review: Organize submissions by category and division for your review. Verify entries are eligible and meet program guidelines and requirements.
- Prepare Reviewers: Ensure reviewers are well-prepared and consistent in their evaluations by providing the Reviewer Packet and direct support throughout the scoring process.
- Collect Scores: Have judges record their points and share final scores to be verified. Double check all entries are scored on all criteria.
- Find Winners: Combine points and rank the artwork to find your winners based on the award categories your PTA set. In the case of ties, the entry with the higher score for interpretation of theme wins.
Recruit Volunteer Reviewers
Seek arts professionals in your community who can score entries based on the criteria provided. If you don't know where to start, connect with an arts teacher at your school or a local craft store to better understand opportunities for connection in your community.
Consider these tips to guide recruitment:
- Determine the number of reviewers needed. Aim for at least one reviewer per category, with extra judges for categories with many entries.
- Use personalize outreach. Send direct invitations to community members, parents and alumni with art backgrounds.
- Be transparent. In your recruitment and invitations, share high-level details explaining the role and time commitment so volunteers understand expectations.
- Encourage recommendations. Ask members and participants to recommend artists in their network who may be interested.